[personal profile] thenostalgicmod
Please comment on this post if you can help clarify any of these queries. Thank you!

Past Queries: Query 1 | Query 2

Avatar: The Last Airbender )

Pocket Monsters | Pokemon - All Media Types )

Video Blogging RPF )
[personal profile] thenostalgicmod
Please comment on this post if you can help clarify any of these queries. Thank you!

Past Queries: Query 1

Carrie - All Media Types )

DC's Arrowverse )

Doctor Who & Related Fandoms )

Original Work )

VeggieTales )
[personal profile] thenostalgicmod
I apologize for the considerable delay and any inconvenience that may have caused.

Please comment on this post if you can help clarify any of these queries. Thank you! Please reply within 24 hours (by May 17 9:15pm EDT). Sign-ups will open by 9:30pm EDT (an hour later than initially planned).

Past Queries: Query 1 | Query 2 | Query 3 | Query 4

1872 (Comics)

    I am not familiar with this fandom, but according to the Fandom-Specific Disambiguations guidelines, it seems that "1872 (Comics)" characters and relationships should be nominated under "Marvel (Comics)".

    For the following, could someone please confirm that this is true? Else, I'll assume yes and accept under "Marvel (Comics)", specifying using "(1872)".

    • Steve Rogers/Tony Stark


Overwatch (Video Game)

    Could someone please confirm that "Solider: 76" and "Slasher: 76" are to be treated as separate characters? Else, I'll assume they are different and accept as is.


Les Misérables - All Media Types

    To streamline nominations, would it be possible to use only specific media versions of Les Mis? I'd be willing to accept any media types.

    If this would be alright, could the nominator please comment on this post to specify which? On the other hand, if All Media Types would be a better fandom than a specific version, please provide a short explanation why and I'll accept as is. Else, I won't accept.


Pocket Monsters | Pokemon - All Media Types

    To streamline nominations, would it be possible to use only specific media versions of Pokemon? I'd be willing to accept any media types.

    If this would be alright, could the nominator please comment on this post to specify which? On the other hand, if All Media Types would be a better fandom than a specific version, please provide a short explanation why and I'll accept as is. Else, I won't accept.


The Sandman (Comics)

    I am not familiar with this fandom, but according to the Fandom-Specific Disambiguations guidelines, it seems that "The Sandman (Comics)" characters and relationships should be nominated under "DCU (Comics)".

    For the following, could someone please confirm that this is true? Else, I'll assume yes and accept under "DCU (Comics)", specifying using "(The Sandman)".

    • Solo: Thessaly
[personal profile] thenostalgicmod
Please comment on this post if you can help clarify any of these queries. Thank you!

Past Queries: Query 1 | Query 2 | Query 3

Crossover Fandom

    For the following, please specify the fandom for each character in the relationship as demonstrated in the nomination guidelines. Else, I won't accept.

    • Buffy Summers/Ash Williams
    • Herbert West/Ash Williams
    • Mia/Ash Williams


Fake AH Crew & Related Fake Rooster Teeth Associate Groups

    Could someone please confirm that this is the best name for this fandom? Is this the correct source to reference? And if so, would one of the Rooster Teeth Shows not be a more specific choice?

    I'd greatly appreciate some clarification regarding what exactly the nominated fandom refers to. Until then, I won't accept.


The King in Yellow - Robert W. Chambers

    For the following, could someone please confirm that Castilla is a character with no other aliases? Else, I'll assume yes and accept as is.

    • Castilla/The King in Yellow


Le Fantôme de l'Opéra | Phantom of the Opera & Related Fandoms

    To streamline nominations, would it be possible to use only specific media versions of Phantom of the Opera? For the moment, "Phantom of the Opera - Lloyd Webber" has been accepted. I'd be willing to accept other media types as well.

    If this would be alright, I'll leave alone the tags nominated under & Related Fandoms for the nominator to change and add to a specific fandom, if they wish.
[personal profile] thenostalgicmod
A quick clarification regarding nominations, especially under "Original Work: Solo Nonhuman Character | 1+ Nonhuman Characters in Ships".

Originally, I had imagined that the category X would probably be used for characters or creatures that the nominator headcanons as something along the lines of objects, things, or "it" rather than "he"/"she"/"them", etc.

If there is a monster, creature, non-human entity, or animated object that you have a gender and/or sex headcanon about when nominating, please try to use that in place of X.

For example, if you headcanon a particular djinn as female, you may use F to indicate that instead of X. Similarly, if you have a headcanon that djinns, as a "species", have gender and/or sex but you do not care what it is for your ship, you may use A to indicate that.

I bring this up because I came across several nominations that had a category built into them but used X. I accepted a few before noticing, and then changed the X to the category indicated in the nomination.

For example, I've changed "(X & X) Ghost Girl & Ghost Kitten (OWNH)" to "(F & A) Ghost Girl & Ghost Kitten (OWNH)".
For example, I've changed "(X) Solo: Female Virtual Assistant (OWNH)" to "(F) Solo: Female Virtual Assistant (OWNH)".

Below are some ships that confused me because there seems to be a category built into the nomination. There are also other nominations which contain non-human creatures that are often associated with some sort of gender and/or sex but were categorized as X. But I do not want to change any these myself because that wouldn't feel right.

  • (X/M) Selkie/Man Who Steals Her Sealskin (OWNH)
  • (X/M) Reverse Anglerfish Mermaid/Man Who Was Hoping For the Other Kind of Mermaid (OWNH)


If you've nominated these (or something similar that hasn't been approved yet), please either change the X to indicate the category you headcanoned, or let me know that you'd prefer to keep X either by commenting (Anonymous is fine!) or sending an email to implodinglittlehearts@gmail.com. Until these are changed or the nominator confirms that they'd prefer to use X, I won't accept them.
[personal profile] thenostalgicmod
Please comment on this post if you can help clarify any of these queries. Thank you!

The Avengers (Marvel Movies)

    As per the Fandom-Specific Disambiguations guidelines, it appears that "The Avengers (Marvel Movies)" should not be nominated as a separate fandom. Rather, these characters or relationships should be nominated to "Marvel Cinematic Universe".

    For the following, could someone please confirm that this is true? Else, I'll accept them under "Marvel Cinematic Universe" and disambiguate with "(MCU)".

    • Steve Rogers/Tony Stark
    • Peter Parker/Tony Stark
    • Tony Stark/Stephen Strange


Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magika | Puella Magi Madoka Magica

    For the following, could someone please confirm that Ai-chan is a character with no other aliases? Else, I'll assume this refers to the character from Episode 9 and change to "A.I.-chan/Futaba Sana" before accepting.

    • Ai-chan/Futaba Sana


Plants vs Zombies

    From what I tried reading about the game, it appears that Mushrooms are a sub-category of Plants. In that case, I won't accept the tag because it doesn't seem mutually exclusive.

    For the following, could someone please clarify how Plants and Shrooms are different characters, or if this could be changed to something more specific? Else, I won't accept.

    • Plants & Shrooms


人渣反派自救系统 - 墨香铜臭 | The Scum Villain's Self-Saving System - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù

    Could someone please confirm that "Original Shěn Qīngqiū" and "Shěn Qīngqiū" are to be treated as separate characters? Additionally, where does the piping "Shěn Yuán | Shěn Qīngqiū" come into play?

    For the following, could someone please confirm that neither piping nor "Original Shěn Qīngqiū" should be used? Else, I'll assume all three versions of the character (plain, original, piping) are different, and accept as is.

    • Shàng Qīnghuá & Shěn Qīngqiū
    • Shàng Qīnghuá/Shěn Qīngqiū
    • Shěn Qīngqiū & System
[personal profile] thenostalgicmod
Please comment on this post if you can help clarify any of these queries. Thank you!

DCU (Comics)

    For the following, are there any universes or runs to be specified? Else, I'll accept them under the "DCU (Comics)" umbrella.

    • John Constantine & any
    • Tim Drake & Dick Grayson & Jason Todd & Bruce Wayne & Damian Wayne
    • Zatanna Zatara & any


Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

    For the following, could someone please confirm that "Multiple Falmer" is a type of character? I ask to make sure the nominator didn't mean Multiple Falmers in the plural. Else, I'll accept as is.

    • Female Falmer Servant/Multiple Falmer


Wiedźmin | The Witcher - All Media Types

    To streamline nominations, would it be possible to use only specific media versions of The Witcher? For the moment, "The Witcher (TV)" and "Wiedźmin | The Witcher (Video Game)" have been accepted. I'd be willing to accept the books, RPF, etc. as well.

    If this would be alright, I'll leave alone the tags nominated under All Media Types for the nominators to change and add to a specific fandom, if they wish.


World Wrestling Entertainment

    Could someone please confirm that "Bray Wyatt" and "The Fiend Bray Wyatt" are to be treated as separate characters? Else, I'll assume they are different and accept as is.
Page generated Jul. 8th, 2025 07:39 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios